Physics Today
Jump to Content
Increase text size Decrease text size
  • Sign In
  • View Items in Cart View Cart
  • Advanced
  • Keyword
 
  • Home
  • Print Edition
  • Daily Edition
    • News Picks
    • The Dayside
    • Physics Update
    • Singularities
    • Points of View
    • Politics and Policy
    • Science and the Media
    • Obituaries
    • We Hear That
    • Events Calendar
  • Advertising
  • Buyer's Guide
  • About us
    • Our mission
    • Our people
    • American Institute of Physics
    • Member societies
    • Register
    • Subscribe
    • Submit content
    • Marketing reprints
    • Rights and permissions
    • Help/FAQ
    • Change mailing address
    • Contact us
  • Jobs
    • Job Seeker Login
    • Search Jobs
    • Post Resumes
    • Career Resources
    • For Employers
    • Success Stories
    • Resume Templates
    • About Us
    • Advertising
    • Display Advertising
    • Employer Resources
    • Banner Advertising
    • Security Tips
Follow us: Facebook    Twitter    rss    E-mail alert
  • Table of contents
  • Past issues

yellow star Featured Jobs

  • Search jobs
  • Post jobs
letters

Looking at Both Sides of Einstein's Gravitational Field Equation

 

October 2002 page 76

 

The letter by Alex Harvey ( Physics Today, February 2002, page 73) claims that the term Λ gµν is necessarily an ingredient of the geometrical, or left-hand, side of Einstein's gravitational field equation. The corresponding matter-free (Tµν = 0) solution for Λ > 0 is the de Sitter space, which contains an embedded repulsive force driving particles apart. Accelerated cosmic expansion therefore appears as a natural consequence of the geometry of space-time. This view conflicts with the "majority opinion" by which the Λ term is identified with some kind of "dark energy."

Whichever side of Einstein's equation has Λ , the equations are still solved by the same curved de Sitter space-time, which contrasts with the flat Minkowski space-time obtained when Λ vanishes.

People nevertheless tend to distinguish the two cases because, on the right-hand side, the Λ term is another source of gravity, expressed by a constant times the stress-energy tensor (κTµν). Adopting Tµν = (p + ρ) uµuν + pgµν, the form valid for a perfect fluid with energy density ρ and pressure p, one can define a Λ fluid by setting Λ = κρ . Then the two formulations agree for an equation of state p = - ρ.

Because Λ is a constant, ρ is constant as well, and such a fluid has negative pressure for positive ρ. The relabeling does not change the physics fixed by general relativity: The reformulated cases are equivalent. One should nevertheless be on the alert if ρ is not constant--even a slowly fluctuating field differs from the Λ case.

However, as long as ρ is constant, the difference between the two formulations lies only in the language used to describe physically identical situations. General relativists are well acquainted with similar apparent interpretational ambiguities when different coordinate systems are used to describe the same space-time geometry.

Hartmut Schulz
(hschulz@astro.ruhr-uni-bochum.de)
Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Bochum, Germany

  • Article Tools
  • Enlarge text   Enlarge text
  • Shrink text   Shrink text
  • Comment on this articleWrite a letter to the editor
  • Free this month
  • Toward a Synthesis of the Newtonian and Darwinian Worldviews
  • Eugene Wigner, Nuclear Engineer
  • NAS Finds No Flaws in Nuclear Treaty
  • Who Broke the Embargo? (It's the Wrong Question!)
  • New Books
  • Letters
  • Most popular articles
  • Gedanken experiment: Levitate a physics sitcom?
    Points of View
  • Nanoplasmonics: The physics behind the applications
    February 2011
  • Half-quantum vortices
    Physics Update
  • Quantum criticality
    February 2011

 



SERVICES
Physics Today Jobs
Physics Today Buyers Guide
Event Calendar
Obituaries
DAILY EDITION
The Dayside
News Picks
Science in the Media
Politics & Policy
Singularities
Physics Update
Points of View
THE MAGAZINE
This month in print
Institutional subscriptions
Information for advertisers
READER SERVICE
Register
Sign in
Subscribe
Email alert
MORE INFO
FAQ
Contact us
About Physics Today
Privacy Policy
Marketing reprints
Rights and Permissions

Copyright © by the American Institute of Physics - All rights reserved

Find articles by AUTHORNAME

This PublicationThis Publication
ScitationScitation
SPINSPIN
ScitopiaScitopia
Google ScholarGoogle Scholar
PubMedPubMed